« Return to Search Results

Documents

Formica Report Annex 122: AR 15-6 Investigation (Death of detainee at Temporary Tactical Holding Facility, Al Asad Air Base, January 9, 2004)

DOA | ACLU-RDI 2611
Summary of findings of inquiry into the death of a detainee on January 9, 2004, at Al Asad Air Base. Detainee, probably named Asad, was captured on January 4, 2004 and held at a Temporary Tactical Holding Facility (TTHF) at Al Asad Air Base. On January 6, he was "place in a concertina wire isolation cage ... as punishment for repeatedly talking." During an interrogation on January 6, detainee "unexpectedly lunged at [redacted]" and "fought hard for one or two minutes" before being subdued and handcuffed. He provided information regarding the location of an IED, and accompanied military personnel when they went to neutralize the IED and locate a weapons cache, and on the return trip "made an effort to escape by opening the truck door." After further interrogations on January 8, he "had repeatedly stood up and tried talking with the guards," who did not speak any Arabic, and had been "punished by the guards for not standing or sitting fast enough with the other detainees." He had been hog-tied "with his arms over his shoulders, his hands tied to at least one foot, and his face to the floor" for at least half an hour. Later that night, he attempted to escape "by stepping over the concertina wire" and was see "moving fast toward the TTHF exit," but was tackled by a a guard and had his legs shackled together. On the morning of January 9, after three attempts to get the detainee to stand up, a guard used flex-cuffs to tie his hands to the top of the metal door frame leading to his cage, exposing bruises on his sides. Detainee "had begun to speak incessantly," whereupon "[redacted]... had attempted to gag him," which required the assistance of another guard to force the detainee's mouth open. "After approximately five to fifteen minutes," detainee "was seen slumped down, hanging by his hands." An ambulance was called but "CPR was unnecessary due to the condition of the body." "Doctor [redacted] arrived at approximately 0900 to pronounce Asad dead." Section on "inconsistencies" is completely redacted. Section on "other relevant facts" notes that the detainee "had not asked for medical attention at any time when he could have been understood," and did not seem to exhibit "any physical disabilities or injuries ... until minutes before" his death. Summary of findings states that he died "due to injuries sustained during an escape attempt" and "the placement of a gag in his mouth by guards." Document includes memo dated January 14, 2004, appointing [redacted] Investigation Officer. Final 3 pages of document are a Memorandum for Record regarding an Informal Commander's Inquiry into allegations that SPC [redacted] assaulted a detainee at Ar Ramadi on October 30, 2003. Memo is labeled "Formica Report – Annex 122" but seems to refer to the same incident discussed in ACLU-RDI 2612 ("Formica Report – Annex 123"). Most likely a labeling error.
AUTHORING AGENCIES:
RECEIVING AGENCIES:
INCIDENTS OF ABUSE MENTIONED:
  • 2003-10-30, Ar Ramadi, Iraq
    • Assault of a detainee at Ar Ramadi by SPC [redacted]. SPC [redacted] "entered the detainee holding area" and "struck the detainee three or four times." Informal Commander's Inquiry found "no evidence that the detainee attempted to escape or provoked the assault." Incident was witnessed by PFC [redacted], who "promptly entered the detainee cell ... and verbally instructed SPC [redacted] to stop. SPC [redacted] obeyed these instructions."
  • 2004-01-09, Al Asad Airbase, Iraq, Death
    • On or around January 9, 2004, an Iraqi detainee died at the Forward Operating Base (FOB) Rifles Base detention Facility in Al Asad, Iraq. Investigations determined that the detainee attempted to escape, however, he was apprehended by two or more officers. The officers retrained the detainee with zip ties, slammed him into a wall, bear hugged him, slammed him to the floor, stood on top of him, and using a military police baton brought the detainee to his feet and pulled him into a standing position. The soldiers then handcuffed the detainee to the door frame of his cell in a manner that forced him to remain standing, the officers then gagged the detainee. The report indicates that the forceful use of the baton fractured the detainee's hyoid bone, and that was the major contributing factor to the detainee's death.